Wednesday, September 28, 2005

Iraqis Call Lynndie England Jail Term Travesty

Published on Wednesday, September 28, 2005 by Reuters
by Waleed Ibrahim

BAGHDAD - Iraqis expressed fury on Wednesday over the three-year jail sentence for Lynndie England, the U.S. soldier notorious for holding a naked inmate by a leash in Abu Ghraib prison, saying it exposed American hypocrisy.

They said the sentence would have been more harsh had she been convicted of abusing Americans.

"America should be ashamed of this sentence. This is the best evidence that Americans have double standards," said Akram Abdel Amir, a retired bus driver in Baghdad.

"There are Iraqis in jail without any charge, just based on suspicion. But when it comes to Americans, the matter is totally different."

England, 22, was sentenced on Tuesday by a U.S. military court after being convicted of abuse, including being photographed pointing to the genitals of a naked Iraqi prisoner.

The former West Virginia chicken factory worker, who had faced a maximum sentence of nine years, was also given a dishonorable discharge.

She is the last of a group of U.S. soldiers to be convicted of abuse at Abu Ghraib, including her former boyfriend and the father of her child, Charles Graner, who is serving 10 years.

"If the abuse was committed against Americans I am sure the sentence would be much harsher. The sentence is nothing compared to what she has done," said laborer Muntasser Abdel Moneim, 30.


The prosecution asked the jury for a sentence of four to six years. England was found guilty on six counts on Monday.

The prisoner abuse scandal provoked global outrage and deepened Iraqi resentment of occupying U.S. troops.

In pre-sentencing testimony, England said she was sorry for her actions but remained an American patriot.

Iraqis remember her as the American soldier who held an inmate by a leash like the kind used for dogs, a highly degrading act because Iraqis and other Muslims regard the animals as unclean.

The images of a smiling England abusing naked inmates were especially humiliating in Iraq, a male-dominated society.

"The whole thing is theater. The Americans want to pretend they defend human rights and are a civilized nation," said Munir Abdel Sahib, a university lecturer.

"I believe that England would not have committed these crimes without orders from above."

In court testimony, England blamed her involvement on Graner, the abuse ringleader, who is now married to another woman who pleaded guilty to abusing prisoners at Abu Ghraib.

"There is no justice in this sentence because the pictures were very shameful. She has to get more years in jail and she has to be imprisoned in Iraq," said Najaat al-Azawi, 55, a retired engineer.

Grocery store owner Hussein Ali said the fact that England faced trial was positive but stressed justice was not served.

"It means the Americans can get away with everything in Iraq. Three years is not enough for what she has done."

U.S. forces are holding about 11,800 prisoners at several detention centers in Iraq, including 4,000 at Abu Ghraib.

Iraqi families, human rights groups and some Iraqi government ministers, including the justice minister, complain too many Iraqis are being wrongfully detained for too long without due process.

Please allow me to state my Bona Fides: I have been against almost everything the Bush administration has done since stealing power in 2000. I was shocked, horrified and angry when I saw even a few photos of the prisoners being abused in Abu Ghraib.

I have been working, specifically on war crimes committed by my own government for years now.


But, if there are any Iraqis out there, reading this, I have a couple of questions:

1) Did I miss the outrage about the guys involved, many out-ranking England? I may have been, as I have been very busy trying to hold the real, evil bastards accountable.

2) Chances are that England was not playing with a full-deck; a brick less than a load, you know? If it makes you feel any better, these were American prison guards, who had first abused and humiliated Americans in jails and prisons all across this country.

3) As a psychologist, I can merely observe her and know that she is not who should suffer the full consequences of this atrocity.

We all know exactly who should really be held accountable!



Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home